CHRIS MATTHEWS: The foreign relations committee of the Continental Congress is weighing the nomination of Thomas Jefferson to be ambassador to France. Tommy Jefferson – Virginia planter, great writer, so-so politician. There's a lot of heat over this one. Muskets are blasting. Let's run to the hearings.
CHAIRMAN: Meeting will come to order. Mr. Jefferson, welcome.
THOM. JEFFERSON: It's a pleasure to be among friends.
CHAIRMAN: You may take off your wig if you like.
JEFFERSON: Thank you, I will.
CHAIRMAN: As you know, your nomination has attracted much praise and much scorn. We're here to get to the facts. We'll start with Delegate Boxer.
BOXER: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Jefferson, as a woman, as a pro-choice mother, I believe we must reach out to other nations.
JEFFERSON: So do I.
BOXER: Oh, I don't think so. I've read your Declaration of Independence, and I'm very upset.
JEFFERSON: What don't you like?
BOXER: It's belligerent. It's unilateral. It sends all the wrong messages. We need a man who'll win friends, not lose them.
JEFFERSON: Could you be specific?
BOXER: Yes. You say, right at the start, "When in the Course of human Events, it becomes necessary for one People to dissolve the Political Bands.." Am I correct so far?
JEFFERSON: Yes, I wrote that. I think John Adams changed a word or two.
BOXER: "Dissolve," Mr. Jefferson? Just split off? Go our own way? Without any multinational approval?
JEFFERSON: Well, I don't know who you'd call.
BOXER: You don't. And you want to represent us in a country that prepares quiche.
JEFFERSON: What does eating have to do with this?
BOXER: And then you write, "We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal.." Did you say that?
JEFFERSON: Guilty.
BOXER: Mr. Jefferson, do you know how arrogant that sounds? Who are we? You neo-revolutionaries think we're the center of the universe, the only people who count on our small planet. And "self-evident"? You're going to meet graduates of the Sorbonne and say "self-evident?"
JEFFERSON: Yes.
BOXER: I need a break.
CHRIS MATTHEWS: We're back with "Hardball." With me is Katrina Vanden Heuvel, editor of The Nation. Katrina, what'd you think?
VANDEN HEUVEL: Disgusting. The man is a rich Virginia hick.
MATTHEWS: You think he'd mess up in France?
VANDEN HEUVEL: He'd be a disaster. Don't forget, Chris, his last declaration started a war. That's the neo-rev plan – more wars, more American power. Then we wonder why they hate us.
MATTHEWS: What else don't you like?
VANDEN HEUVEL: He's a southern religious nut. He says in that so-called declaration he wrote, "endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.." He's going to say that to the king of France?
MATTHEWS: I get your drift. Quickly, if he goes down, who's your choice to replace him?
VANDEN HEUVEL: Well, it's too bad we lost Benedict Arnold. At least the man knew now to relate to other countries. I'll have to think.
MATTHEWS: They're starting again. Let's go back to the combat.
CHAIRMAN: Chair recognizes the gentleman from Massachusetts, Mr. Kerry.
KERRY: Thank you. You know, Mr. Jefferson, I fought in the Revolution.
JEFFERSON: Yes, I've heard.
KERRY: I was right there with the troops, until I decided we'd been at it too long. Then I came back, and in good conscience, as a patriot…
JEFFERSON: Yes, I've heard.
KERRY: But that's the past. Mr. Jefferson, have you ever lived in France?
JEFFERSON: No.
KERRY: I have. Studied there. My wife speaks several languages.
JEFFERSON: Yes, I've heard.
KERRY: And I'm worried about your style. I understand, when the Declaration was being written, you kind of bullied the other delegates.
JEFFERSON: Bullied?
KERRY: You and John Adams went at it. You tried to have his changes taken out.
JEFFERSON: Well, we disagreed.
KERRY: Makes me uncomfortable when a man doesn't tolerate dissent.
JEFFERSON: Now, wait, it was my Declaration.
BOXER: Let me get in here. So it's about property rights, and ownership.
JEFFERSON: I didn't say that.
BOXER: If it had been written by someone a little more sensitive, and diplomatic, it would have been our Declaration. Ours. Men and women, gay and straight, including dissenters. We are a community!
JEFFERSON: Yes, that's what I tried to say.
BOXER: And the way you end this Declaration – we pledge "our Lives, our Fortunes, and our sacred Honor." How macho, Mr. Jefferson. And you want to go to the most feminine of nations?
JEFFERSON: I can handle it.
BOXER: I need a break.
CHRIS MATTHEWS: Fireworks. Blood on the floor. Katrina, what'd you think?
VANDEN HEUVEL: He's bully boy with a big house.
MATTHEWS: You think Jefferson's his own man?
VANDEN HEUVEL: You kidding?
MATTHEWS: Who runs him?
VANDEN HEUVEL: Chris, read The Nation next week. We're ripping the lid off, exposing this man for what he is.
MATTHEWS: Gimme a heads up.
VANDEN HEUVEL: We call it, "Thom. Jefferson – Front Man for Ariel Sharon."
William Katz is a New York writer, author of ten books, and a former editor on The New York Times Magazine.